When Iceberg tables are wrong, nothing crashes.
There’s no smoke, no fire, and no alarms. In fact, jobs show success, and dashboards continue to load.
But the numbers are wrong.
Metadata now dictates reality. The table is no longer a storage format, it's a logical state.
If a file exists in S3 but isn't in the metadata, it doesn't exist to the engine. And if the metadata points to an old version of a file, that old version IS the truth now.
But that logical state lacks a cross‑system sanity check between the catalog, storage, and downstream consumers.
And that’s a problem.
Iceberg is a Metadata System
If you grew up in the era of Hive, you're used to the idea that 'the folder is the table.' You put Parquet files in a directory, and the query engine assumed that whatever it found there was authoritative.
Query engines discovered data by inspecting directories and file layouts directly. Physical structure and logical structure were effectively the same thing.
Apache Iceberg breaks that link.
In Iceberg, files in object storage are inert. They don't define a table on their own. The query engine never scans directories to determine what data exists. It asks the catalog for instructions and follows them.
Because the engine no longer validates physical layout, metadata becomes the sole authority for table state. It's the only thing standing between a correct result and a successful query that returns incorrect data.
The Power of Iceberg’s Logical Table State
This shift (from physical files to logical metadata) is what gives Iceberg its power. Because the table is now defined by a set of instructions rather than a physical directory, we gain levels of control that felt impossible five years ago:
ACID Transactions: No more partial reads or corrupted tables because a Spark job crashed. The metadata catalog only swaps the current pointer once the entire write is successful. It's all-or-nothing.
Time Travel: Want to see the table as it looked last Tuesday? You don't restore a backup; you just tell the metadata to point the engine to an older Snapshot ID.
Partition Evolution: You can change how your table is partitioned without rewriting a single byte of data. The metadata tracks the old logic for old data and the new logic for new data.
But there's a catch.
The Hidden Cost of Iceberg’s Metadata Architecture
Every one of those capabilities leaves a footprint. Every INSERT, UPDATE, or DELETE creates a new snapshot, a new manifest list, and a new set of manifest files.
You've escaped S3 Folder Hell, but entered the realm of Metadata Bloat. If not careful, you'll end up with thousands of orphan data files and stale snapshots that serve no purpose other than slowing down your query planning and busting up your cloud budget.
The Metadata Ripple Effect in Iceberg Tables
In traditional databases, failures tend to be obvious. Queries error out, jobs fail, and someone gets paged.
In Iceberg-based architectures, failures aren't as clearly cut.
Everything looks healthy. S3 buckets are full. Spark jobs report success. And Parquet files sit exactly where they're supposed to.
Downstream, dashboards load without complaint, but the results are wrong.
This is the ripple effect of metadata drift.
Invisible Data Caused by Iceberg Metadata Drift
If the metadata fails to update, your data gets lost in plain sight. The files might be sitting in your S3 bucket, but they never make it onto the table's official ledger.
Because the query engine only reads what that ledger tells it to, it ignores the unrecorded files entirely.
No error, no alarm, just a partial dataset presented as the absolute truth.
For example: a Spark job successfully writes tens of thousands of new Parquet files, but the final handshake to update the table fails. The files are sitting there in S3, but because the new snapshot was never committed, your BI tools continue to query the previous snapshot as if nothing happened.
Dashboards load, SLAs stay green, and you're confidently reporting yesterday's truth.
Upstream Iceberg Schema Changes, Downstream Impact
Iceberg allows engineers upstream to evolve schemas quickly. They can drop columns and change data types at will. But downstream systems aren't quite as flexible.
So, dbt models, BI tools, and semantic layers continue to expect the previous structure. This means that pipelines succeed, but the outputs no longer mean what consumers think they mean.
Iceberg Metadata Accumulation and Snapshot Bloat
Metadata accumulates with every transaction. Without regular maintenance, this metadata bloat slows query planning to a crawl as engines struggle to span massive manifest lists.
The result is a dual penalty: degraded performance for your users and rising storage costs for physical files that are no longer part of your logical table.
None of these failures announces itself. They compound quietly until someone notices the numbers don't line up.
Why Traditional Observability Fails for Iceberg
The real frustration is that the numbers are wrong, but your monitoring tools told you they were right.
Traditional tools perform a pulse check on the data by scanning rows for nulls, checking numeric distributions, and monitoring volume. But in the Iceberg world, the data isn't the problem. It's the metadata.
Legacy observability ignores the metadata catalog. It sees that your physical files are healthy, so it gives you a thumbs-up and a green light. It doesn't realize that:
- The statistics are wrong: Your manifest files have incorrect min/max stats, causing the engine to skip the very data you are trying to monitor.
- The lineage is broken: Your tool can't see the invisible metadata handoff happening between your Spark job and your Snowflake table.
When you rely on row-level checks for an Iceberg table, you are monitoring the bricks while the house is being demolished at the metadata level.
You need a Metadata Control Plane that treats the metadata layer for what it is: the primary source of truth.
Sifflet Data Observability: The Reality Check for Apache Iceberg
Iceberg enforces transactional correctness, but doesn't validate cross-system consistency. That gap is outside the table format.
Precisely the gap Sifflet Data Observability is designed to fill.
Instead of waiting for a downstream dashboard to break, Sifflet continuously reconciles the logical state of your Iceberg tables with what actually lives in object storage and what downstream tools think the schema is.
- Cross-checking catalog vs. storage
Sifflet connects to your Iceberg catalog, your object store, and your query engines. It continuously analyzes Iceberg snapshots and metadata, along with storage-level signals, to surface issues such as orphaned or missing data files and problematic partition layouts.
- Concrete drift detection
When a Spark job writes files but fails to commit the snapshot, Sifflet sees new objects in S3 that aren't referenced by any Iceberg manifest. It flags the table as having orphan data, surfaces the offending snapshot boundary, and enriches those findings with lineage and behavioral context, helping engineers quickly identify the jobs or assets most likely responsible for the drift.
- Schema and contract awareness
Sifflet tracks schema changes in your Iceberg tables and uses metadata it ingests from dbt, warehouses, and BI tools to detect schema and contract changes before they appear as broken or misleading dashboards.
This is beyond monitoring. It’s a cross-system reconciliation. It’s the independent validation that makes Apache Iceberg's power safe to use.
Closing the Observability Loop in the Iceberg Era
Apache Iceberg provides the blueprint, and your query engines provide the muscle. But in this decoupled world, no one checks whether the blueprint actually matches the building.
Sifflet provides the independent reality check this architecture lacks. It reconciles the logical state in your catalog with the physical reality of your storage, guaranteeing your engines always work from the truth.
The Iceberg Era should represent a leap forward in reliability, not a new way to fly blind. Elevate your data stack with the control plane it deserves and turn your metadata from a liability into your greatest asset.
Take control of your Iceberg stack with Sifflet.
%2520copy%2520(3).avif)
-p-500.png)
